On Stories

A gift for someone who has everything — and the one thing they genuinely don't.

On the impossible gift problem — and what the person who has everything genuinely, structurally cannot already own.

Juno8 min read

It is November, or it is three weeks before a significant birthday, or it is the week before Christmas, and someone in the family says the sentence. They always say the same sentence. What do you get someone who has everything? And then everyone in the room goes quiet, not because they don't have suggestions, but because they have already made the suggestions internally and rejected them.

What having everything actually means.

The phrase is loose, but it is pointing at something real. It does not mean the person is wealthy. What it means is that the person is settled. They have accumulated, across years, the objects and experiences and relationships that constitute a full life. The marginal return on a new jumper, when a person already has the jumpers they want, is close to zero. You are, essentially, trying to fill a container that is already full.

Which raises the useful question: is there anything a complete person genuinely lacks? The answer is yes. And it is, almost always, the same answer: they lack a record.

The experiential gift trap.

In the past twenty years, the conventional wisdom on gifts for people who have everything has converged on a single answer: give them an experience, not a thing. The reasoning is elegant but the execution is where it falls apart. Experiences are time-sensitive. They expire. The cooking class voucher in the drawer is not just a reminder of a gift. It is a small reproach.

The deeper problem is that an experience, even a beautiful one, is consumed. It happens, and then it is in the past. The weekend in the mountains becomes a story. The escape room becomes an afternoon that ended in traffic.

The one thing they cannot already own.

There is a category of thing that is structurally impossible to have already. Not because it is expensive or rare. But because it does not exist until someone makes it, and it can only be made by the people who know them, and it can only be made for them. It is a record. A record of themselves, written by the people who were paying attention, in the form of a story, set down on a page and bound in a hardcover, with their name matte-printed on the cover.

“The most generous thing you can give someone is proof that you were paying attention.”
— Juno

What the record contains.

The record contains the things that are true of only this one person. The way they move around the kitchen at six in the morning. The thing they say when they are doing something they don't want to do but have decided to do anyway. The argument they have never quite stopped making, though they have never yet won it. These specifics do not come from research. They come from the people who have been watching, for years, without necessarily realising that the watching was the thing of value.

The form of the thing.

A storybook made for one person at sundayfawn is a hardcover storybook written for one named reader. Matte-printed on the cover. Thirty-two pages. There is no tier, no upgrade. One book, one edition of one.

After the book ships, the file is closed. There is no reprinting on request. The book the person holds is structurally the only one — the edition of one is both a description and a promise.

A few questions people ask at this point.

What if they are private? The book is not an invasion. The brief asks for the things the person would want to have noticed, not the things they would not. Specifics about kindness, about habits of attention, about the particular quality of their presence — these are not invasions. They are the record a person has been earning for years without anyone having the right form to put them in.

What if I don't know what to say? That is the brief. You do not write the book. You write a page of specifics and the studio writes the book from them. The brief takes about ten minutes. The studio takes a few weeks.

What to do next.

Think of three specifics. Not the ones that would go in a card. The ones that would only be said about this person, by someone who had been watching for years. If you can think of three, you have everything you need. The press is here if you decide to make one.

— A storybook no one else has ever read.

end of essay

Continue reading

The press, indexed

Browse the full catalogue